Supernatural: Who's on top?

[jasmasson]

After the conflicting messages of physicaltop!Sam and prissybitchbottom!Sam from Tall Tales I'm all confused. Just who is on top? It's keeping me awake at nights. Put your own justifications in the comments if you don't like mine ;-)

[Poll #934993]

Comments

[lorelei633.livejournal.com]

Bwahahahaaaaaaaa! I love you! *smooch*

[jasmasson.livejournal.com]

*giggles* *snogs*

[lorelei633.livejournal.com]

I see you and I are in complete agreement on this.

Have you seen how big he is?

Oh yeah. ;)

[jasmasson.livejournal.com]

LOL! We always see eye to eye on who should top and who should bottom. (poor ratboy ;-)

[lorelei633.livejournal.com]

Hee! Yes, poor ratboy. Oh, well. Not our fault he looks so good in a pair of handcuffs! ;)

[lemmealone.livejournal.com]

I'd love to say they switch off, but Dean? Under all that macho and stubble lurks a big nelly bottom. He loves the cock. Also, Huge Sam with his hands surrounding Dean's hips... fgnuh. It's not an issue of characterisation for me so much as hi, HOT. *g*

[jasmasson.livejournal.com]

Whoa! That's almost comment porn you got right there ;-) Hotdamn! If I didn't think so already, I totally would now!!

[lorelei633.livejournal.com]

I second that emotion. Between the comment porn and the icon porn, I need a cigarette. ;)

[imagination55.livejournal.com]

I have a kink for top!Sam but for some reason, my head made me tick that they switch/share the duty.

Hmm. I dunno. Got ME wondering now!

Sam's utter hugeness is a definite factor...I swear he picked Dean up prior to the wall slam in Salvation and he practically threw him down on the bed in Tall Tales...

Strangely enough, I can't think of much to add to make a better Dean case...

Guess I'm falling down on the top!Sam/bottom!Dean side by default *g* ALTHOUGH I think Dean must have taught him all he knows! ;o)

I commend you on a very valid and thought provoking question/poll! :)

[jasmasson.livejournal.com]

*g* Sam's size just is compelling. I'm pretty sure he won that wrestling match (Kripke, you tease, why couldn't we see?!

[eboniorchid.livejournal.com]

technosage actually has a really awesome meta on the top/bottom status of the boys, and explains it a lot more eloquently than I ever could, but here goes.

They might switch on occasion, probably do in certain circumstances, just because they're about pleasing each other and making sure each other's needs are met. But, for the most part, Sam's the top. Dean's supposedly butch in the sense that he's more likely to break shit than talk about his feelings, BUT he also defers to the people he trusts in most instances. I think the boys' interactions with their father are probably the most telling, actually, about who would most likely be toppy and who would be bottomy between them. Sam might not be the violent type, but he always wants all the information and he'll get in your face if he doesn't agree with you, so it's not like being "sensitive" means he's a pushover. He's stubborn as hell. Dean, on the other hand, can yell back, but if he really trusts the person, in the end, he'll give in, whether it's his dad or his brother. And when it comes to who is more dependent, honestly, Sam might look to Dean for support sometimes, but Dean's much more likely to fall apart without Sam being basically the focus of his life. I'd say Dean's probably not all that bottomy in general, but for Sam? Hell yes.

Oh, and then then there's that whole image of Sam bending Dean over the hood of the Imapala and fucking him until there's come leaking down the front grate and their sweat has ruined the wax job. Of course, they don't care because Sam thinks it's hot when Dean get's all dirty working on the car, which might have been how they ended up on the hood in the first place. And really, it wasn't too much of an issue because they were staying at a cabin by a lake this week and when they'd rested up a bit more, they were totally going to go for a dip. Sam would fuck Dean half in the water and half out until they both had wet sand in their hair and under their fingernails and they hoped fish liked jizz, 'cause they were too tired to get out their other rods in order to catch some dinner tonight.

... wait ... nevermind ...

*runs away*

[jasmasson.livejournal.com]

Gah! You must totally write that! Pleasepleaseplease!

[deadbeat-nymph.livejournal.com]

I'm all about bottom Dean, but I do appreciate their switch potential.